Considerate Dental Care


Helpful Patient Forms

Find the forms that you need to fill out in order to make your first appointment with us a breeze. We work with most insurance companies!


About Dental Care

Learn more about our dental services. Leave a review to be entered into a drawing for an in-office Zoom whitening (worth $500)!


Meet Our Staff

Find out more about the dedicated team at Benchmark Dental of Greeley and the high degree of professionalism you'll receive from a staff with 13 years of experience.

With our convenient location in Greeley, CO, we are your local family friendly dental office, caring for patients from Greeley and the surrounding communities of Evans, Lucerne, LaSalle, Eaton, Galeton, Fort Collins, Loveland, and more. 

Why Choose Us?

We manage everything from your children’s checkups to implant placement, cosmetic dentistry, implant-supported dentures, KÖR and Zoom whitening, root canals, and Invisalign.   We perform most procedures in-house, so you rarely need a referral to a specialist.  

The team at Benchmark Dental of Greeley love getting to know their patients and care for you as if you were family.  Their goal is to create and nurture relationships that last generations and use the latest in dental technology to ensure your treatment is quick, affordable, and virtually pain-free.  

We provide quality dental care, conveniently in your neighborhood and cater to your schedule. Because your comfort is important to us, we offer many of the modern amenities you’ve come to expect in a dental office. We believe that whatever your dental needs may be, you will be treated with the highest quality dentistry available and with the most compassionate, respectful care you deserve. 

Dental Implants

Dental implants bring the ultimate solution for missing teeth. Dr. Custer and Dr. Arritt bring their expertise to direct your implant case at every stage.

Teeth Whitening

Teeth whitening at Benchmark Dental of Greeley means a whiter smile is well within reach. Find out how we quickly remove years of stain for brilliant results.


Invisalign brings stealth straightening to you with thin, invisible trays. Benchmark Dental of Greeley’s experience puts a stunning smile within easy reach.

Meet the Dentist


Dr. Shawn Custer

Nebraska born and raised, Dr. Custer received his Bachelor's degree in Biological Science from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and his Doctorate of Dental Surgery from the University of Nebraska Medical Center College of Dentistry.
As Dr. Custer believes in the importance of patient experience in clinical dentistry, he feels that pain control and comfort is a must and strives to treat patients like family.



Patient Reviews

Clients of Benchmark Dental of Greeley really enjoy coming to our office and have nothing but good things to say about us!

"I hated going to the dentist until I found Benchmark. Friendly knowledgeable staff that takes the scary out of dental work."
–Peggy N.
"The people who work there are so polite and explain everything they're going to do before they do it. Haven't found a great dentist office until now. Definitely will recommend them to everyone I know."
–Leigh S.
"Best Dental office ever! ALWAYS on time, always helpful, and always professional and fun!"
–Pamela S.
"Nice folks. Doc has good bedside manner. Clean, comfortable office. Good experiences for me."
–David M.

Schedule an appointment with our doctors today!